Wii Fit Not Endearing Itself to Everyone
Posted 05-19-2008 at 09:42 AM by RaiseHavok
Nintendo’s Wii Fit has been quite popular as of late. Pre-orders for the package have been selling like hotcakes. The game, which releases this week, seems to have the same widespread appeal that made Wii Sports a hit. However, a recent news report has some speaking out against the popular item.
There has recently been a story circulating around the Internet that details a child’s unfortunate experience with Wii Fit. Apparently, the game, which comes with a scale-like peripheral, measured the girl’s BMI (Body Mass Index) and judged her to be overweight. The girl became very upset and had to be consoled by her mother. As a result, some have begun to pass unfavorable judgment upon Nintendo’s newest cash cow.
The main problem is that this 10-year-old girl probably has a rather limited understanding of the concept of BMI. The game’s calculation probably made her feel inadequate and she responded the only way she knew how. This might simply be a cultural misunderstanding. I don’t know if children in Japan have image issues, but I am willing to bet that the problem isn’t as prevalent as in the United States. Perhaps Nintendo was unaware that the calculation could have such a negative impact on a child. It’s not Nintendo’s job to be surrogate parents, but perhaps they could have included an additional booklet filled with information about BMI and testimonials from medical experts. However, I don’t think Nintendo is at fault in this situation.
Wii Fit, despite the recent news coverage, has tremendous potential. It is no secret that this country has a problem with obesity. Perhaps it wouldn’t be so bad for an overweight child to hear that they need to shed a few pounds. I definitely do not advocate teasing a child about their weight or the use of words like “fat.” However, I fully support Wii Fit if it can help get kids to be more active.
I can’t tell you how much it upsets me to see overweight children. Obesity is often the result of poor choices made throughout one’s life. I understand that some people can’t help the fact that they overweight, but many people in this country eat way too much fast food and candy. The worst part is that many overweight children don’t know any better. They often grow up in an environment where they are allowed to eat whatever they want. Personally, I think there are some pretty terrible parents in this country. Perhaps Wii Fit can do what many parents will not.
Wii Fit isn’t going to whip you into tremendous shape. It might be a decent workout, but nothing compares to going outside for a run or going to the pool for a swim. Hopefully Wii Fit can encourage people to get outside and exercise more often. However, I fear that many people will think that Wii Fit will provide all of the exercise they ever need. Instead of going outside for a walk, children might just turn on Wii Fit for a half an hour and proceed to sit on the couch for the rest of the day. If the child fails to lose weight, they might become discouraged and think that exercise has no benefits. Wii Fit isn’t going to help trim the country’s obesity problems, but perhaps it can act as a gateway to a more active lifestyle.
I feel terrible for this young girl. No one should be made to feel inadequate. Many people in this country have image issues and eating disorders are certainly a serious concern. I understand and sympathize with the mother, but I don’t think that Wii Fit should be demonized. Instead, we should look at Wii Fit as an opportunity to make significant changes to improve our quality of life. Wii Fit has tremendous potential, but only time will tell if it becomes more than a game that families play at holiday gatherings.
There has recently been a story circulating around the Internet that details a child’s unfortunate experience with Wii Fit. Apparently, the game, which comes with a scale-like peripheral, measured the girl’s BMI (Body Mass Index) and judged her to be overweight. The girl became very upset and had to be consoled by her mother. As a result, some have begun to pass unfavorable judgment upon Nintendo’s newest cash cow.
The main problem is that this 10-year-old girl probably has a rather limited understanding of the concept of BMI. The game’s calculation probably made her feel inadequate and she responded the only way she knew how. This might simply be a cultural misunderstanding. I don’t know if children in Japan have image issues, but I am willing to bet that the problem isn’t as prevalent as in the United States. Perhaps Nintendo was unaware that the calculation could have such a negative impact on a child. It’s not Nintendo’s job to be surrogate parents, but perhaps they could have included an additional booklet filled with information about BMI and testimonials from medical experts. However, I don’t think Nintendo is at fault in this situation.
Wii Fit, despite the recent news coverage, has tremendous potential. It is no secret that this country has a problem with obesity. Perhaps it wouldn’t be so bad for an overweight child to hear that they need to shed a few pounds. I definitely do not advocate teasing a child about their weight or the use of words like “fat.” However, I fully support Wii Fit if it can help get kids to be more active.
I can’t tell you how much it upsets me to see overweight children. Obesity is often the result of poor choices made throughout one’s life. I understand that some people can’t help the fact that they overweight, but many people in this country eat way too much fast food and candy. The worst part is that many overweight children don’t know any better. They often grow up in an environment where they are allowed to eat whatever they want. Personally, I think there are some pretty terrible parents in this country. Perhaps Wii Fit can do what many parents will not.
Wii Fit isn’t going to whip you into tremendous shape. It might be a decent workout, but nothing compares to going outside for a run or going to the pool for a swim. Hopefully Wii Fit can encourage people to get outside and exercise more often. However, I fear that many people will think that Wii Fit will provide all of the exercise they ever need. Instead of going outside for a walk, children might just turn on Wii Fit for a half an hour and proceed to sit on the couch for the rest of the day. If the child fails to lose weight, they might become discouraged and think that exercise has no benefits. Wii Fit isn’t going to help trim the country’s obesity problems, but perhaps it can act as a gateway to a more active lifestyle.
I feel terrible for this young girl. No one should be made to feel inadequate. Many people in this country have image issues and eating disorders are certainly a serious concern. I understand and sympathize with the mother, but I don’t think that Wii Fit should be demonized. Instead, we should look at Wii Fit as an opportunity to make significant changes to improve our quality of life. Wii Fit has tremendous potential, but only time will tell if it becomes more than a game that families play at holiday gatherings.
Comments 2
Total Comments 2
Comments
|
|
I'm in agreement, the BMI is not properly explained anywhere in Wii Fit and that is a major failing. To set a target on it makes it even worse, however I'm not sure kids are the target audience for the weight loss aspect (if they are, that's sad).
However, I don't think it's fair to say this isn't a good enough workout. Recommendations are 30 minutes per day of vigourous exercise, and Wii Fit does actively encourage that both directly through comments and through rewards for "Fit Cash". Yes it is possible that people might think 30 minutes then couch potato is an okay routine, but in reality most people will want to keep active having done their workout - they'll shower after and then feel buzzy for a while; and even if they didn't it's 30 minutes more than they were getting before. I think if people are responsible and use Wii Fit as a tool in a larger lifestyle change then they will see a difference - I have been using it for three weeks now and I have seen weight loss. I can climb stairs without getting tired out (and I'm not obese), and I feel all round better in my health. I did a comparative a while back of Wii Fit versus other methods of keeping fit and I rank Wii Fit as one of the best options, if not the overall best. |
Posted 05-19-2008 at 11:49 AM by Destyn
|
|
|
I think that the Wii Fit is a pretty good product to be honest, it may not be as accurate as you'd want, but it definitely does the job in my opinion! I'm yet to feel tired after playing the Wii Fit, but we'll see about that soon I guess!
Free Wii |
Posted 01-01-2009 at 07:16 PM by
|
Recent Blog Entries by RaiseHavok
- Fat Princess getting Frost Bite on Candy Mountain (03-25-2010)
- Atkinson resigns as South Australian attorney general (03-22-2010)
- Warner's LEGO gravy train set to roll on (03-03-2010)
- It's going to be a Nintendo summer (02-24-2010)
- BioShock 2 single-player campaign (02-18-2010)
